Why Some Injury Claims Go To Trial While Others Settle

After an accident, many people wonder whether their case will settle or go to trial. While most injury claims resolve before reaching court, some situations make litigation unavoidable, depending on the evidence, the severity of the injuries, and how insurance companies respond. These decisions are often guided by experienced legal insight. 

Attorney Ira M. Maurer is a nationally recognized personal injury trial lawyer with more than 40 years of experience and over 100 million dollars recovered for injured clients. His extensive trial background and deep medical knowledge allow injury victims to pursue compensation from a position of strength as they explore their legal options.

The Difference Between Settlements And Trials

A settlement happens when both sides agree on compensation without going to court. A trial involves presenting the case before a judge or jury, who then decides the outcome. Each path has advantages and risks, depending on the circumstances of the injury claims involved.

Settlements are often preferred because they are generally:

• Faster than a trial
• Less stressful for injury victims
• More predictable in outcome

Trials, while longer and more complex, may be necessary when fair compensation cannot be reached.

Common Reasons Injury Claims Settle

Many cases settle because the facts are relatively clear. When the fault is obvious and the injuries are well documented, insurance companies may choose to resolve the matter rather than risk a court verdict.

Other reasons claims settle include:

• The injured person needs compensation quickly to cover medical bills
• Both parties want to avoid court costs
• Evidence strongly supports the claim

In these situations, having a personal injury attorney review the offer helps ensure the settlement reflects the true value of the damages.

Why Some Injury Claims Go To Trial

Not every case can be resolved through negotiation. Trials are more likely when insurers dispute responsibility or minimize the seriousness of injuries. Severe injuries with long-term consequences often lead to disagreements about future medical costs and lost income.

A case may proceed to trial if:

• Liability is contested
• The insurance company refuses a reasonable settlement
• Damages are significant and complex

In these scenarios, preparing the case thoroughly becomes essential.

How A Personal Injury Attorney Guides The Decision

A personal injury attorney evaluates the strength of the case, reviews settlement offers, and advises whether pursuing a trial may be in the client’s best interest. This includes gathering evidence, consulting experts, and preparing for court, even when a settlement remains possible.

Strong preparation signals that the claim will be taken seriously, which can influence negotiations.

How Injury Claims Are Handled In Fishkill, NY

Whether an injury claim settles or proceeds to trial depends on the evidence, the extent of the injuries, and the insurance company’s response. Speaking with a personal injury attorney early can make a meaningful difference in protecting rights and avoiding costly mistakes. 

To discuss your situation and learn your options, call 845-896-5295 to schedule a consultation today.